What Card Offices Can Learn from Retail Customer Service
What Card Offices Can Learn from Retail Customer Service

I spent over 12 years working in retail management early in my career, which means I have dealt with my share of unhappy customers who were absolutely certain that whatever had gone wrong was both a personal tragedy and somehow entirely my fault.
And you know what? Some of the lessons I learned standing behind a retail counter have stayed with me years later.
Campus card offices may not feel much like retail. Students are not exactly browsing for a new credential because the old one went out of style. But from a service perspective, many of the interactions are surprisingly similar.
- A student has a problem.
- They need someone to fix it.
- Often they arrive at your counter after that problem has already made their day worse.
- They don't understand the rules and processes you follow
Their card will not open their residence hall. Their meal plan is not working. Their credential disappeared from their phone. They are late for class. Maybe they have already been sent from another office to yours. By the time they get to you, you may be meeting them at the worst five minutes of their day.
That is where good customer service needs to happen the most!
Angry people want to know they have been heard.
One of the most important things I learned in retail is that calming down an angry customer does not always mean you actually solve their problem. You can make a huge impact by showing them you understand their concerns... and know why they are angry.

There is a big difference between hearing someone's words and making that person feel heard. One of the best techniques for doing that is mirroring.
If a student says, "I've already been to housing and they sent me here, and now you're telling me I have to go somewhere else?"
A response like, "So housing sent you here because they thought we could fix the issue, and now it sounds like you are being sent somewhere else again. I understand why that's frustrating," can completely change the tone of the conversation.
You have not fixed anything yet, but you have demonstrated that you were listening.
When someone is upset, jumping immediately into policy or explaining why something happened can sometimes make things worse. Even when your explanation is completely correct, the customer may hear it as, "Here is why your problem isn't our problem."
Acknowledgment comes first, then you can work on the solution.
De-escalation should be something you take the time to learn... and teach.
We spend a lot of time training employees and student workers on systems and processes, but how much time do we spend teaching them what to do when someone is angry or hurting?
Sometimes an employee can be technically correct, but a conversation becomes a debate over who is right, or the employee becomes defensive and they become mad too. But being right is rarely the goal of a customer service interaction; helping the person move toward a solution.
De-escalation is a skill. It should not be something we expect students or new staff members to figure out while someone is yelling at them across the counter. Staff should know how to keep their voice calm, how to acknowledge frustration without accepting inappropriate behavior, and when it is time to bring in a supervisor. This short video goes over some of the basic skills involved in calming a situation, and these are skills we can use in many life situations.
Staying calm does not mean ignoring policies. Sometimes the answer really is no. Good customer service does not mean saying yes to everything. But we should be able to deliver that answer in a way that shows respect for the person standing in front of you.
The stories people remember are about what happened next.
There is another lesson from retail that I think applies especially well to campus card programs.
Meeting expectations is important, but exceeding them is memorable.
Nobody goes to their dorm and tells their roommate, "You would not believe what happened today. I went to the card office because I lost my card and they printed a new one!" That is not much of a story.

But people do tell stories when someone went above and beyond the service that was anticipated. They remember the person who called another department instead of simply handing them a phone number. They remember when someone took ownership of a problem that technically belonged somewhere else. They remember when they are nervous about taking the next step and you walk with them to where they need to go.
Those moments become the stories people tell about your office. Those moments become the stories they tell about their entire relationship with the college or university!
Retail companies know this very well. A customer who has an unexpectedly good experience often becomes far more loyal than someone whose transaction simply went according to plan. Not only do they come back, but they may even pop onto Yelp and give a great review.
There is a campus version of that too. Students talk. Parents talk. Faculty and staff talk. Your reputation is being built one interaction at a time.
Look at your office through the student's eyes.
Retail also taught me to pay attention to the experience around the transaction, not just the transaction itself. The same principle applies in a card office. A process may make perfect sense to us because we work with it every day. To a student using it for the first time, it may be completely confusing.
They may not know which office controls their meal plan or the names of all the companies providing service to the campus. They probably do not know which system feeds data into another system. They definitely do not care that the problem originates in software managed by a different department. They just know their card does not work.
Sometimes excellent customer service begins with remembering how little the customer is supposed to know about our internal processes. And often we don't even need to educate them about this stuff. They just need to know what to do next.
Your front counter is part of your campus brand.
People often think of customer service as something that happens when there is a problem. I think it is bigger than that. Every interaction with the card office teaches someone what kind of organization you are.
Are people welcomed when they walk in? Does someone look up from the computer? Does the employee seem interested in helping, or does the student feel like an interruption? People rarely remember every detail of a transaction. They remember how the interaction felt. The same is true on campus.
And if they leave your office thinking, "Wow, they really took care of me," there is a very good chance someone else will eventually hear that story too.
A student may forget exactly why their credential stopped working three years from now. But they may still remember the person who helped them when it did. And they may still have a good feeling when they walk by your office, knowing that there are people in there who can help.